States Meeting on 20 May & 3 June 2020 (Billets d'Etat XI, XII & Urgent Propositions))

Items discussed at this meeting included the States of Guernsey Energy Policy, Review of the Ecclesiastical Court, Diffuse Mesothelioma Payment Scheme and Replacement of the Electronic Patient Records System.

• Watch the States' Meeting online

  • You can watch previous live streams of the States' Meeting below: 
  • • Wednesday 20th May
    • Thursday 21st May
    • Friday 22nd May
    • Wednesday 3rd June
    • Thursday 4th June
       
    • BBC Guernsey also broadcast the audio of the meeting live through their website here or you can listen via BBC Radio Guernsey's 1116MW frequency

• Statements 

  • Statement to be given by	Topic
    Committee for Economic Development	Work on the business case on the extension of the runway at Guernsey Airport
    States' Trading Supervisory Board	Aurigny announcement regarding cancellation of flights

• Questions 

  • Questioner	Committee	Topic
    Deputy J.A.B. Gollop	Policy & Resources Committee	Financial assistance for bodies affected by the pandemic [492kb]
    Deputy J.A.B. Gollop	Committee for Economic Development	Recovery and regeneration strategies [498kb]

• Urgent Propositions in Pursuance of Rule 18 

  • Committee/Body	Title	Proposition Reference	Status
    Civil Contingencies Authority	Emergency Powers (Coronavirus) (General Provision) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (No.2) Regulations, 2020	P.2020/100	Approved
    Amendment 1	Deputy Dorey & Deputy Ferbrache [504kb]	P.2020/100 Amdt 1	Lost
    Voting Record	Amendment 1 [108kb]	n/a	n/a
    Voting Record	Motion under Rule 24.(6) on Amendment 1 [109kb]	n/a	n/a
    Amendment 2	Amendment 2 - Deputy Tindall & Deputy Oliver [340kb]	P.2020/100 Amdt 2	Not Laid
    Amendment 3	Amendment 3 - Deputy Tindall & Deputy Oliver [341kb]	P.2020/100 Amdt 3	Not Laid
    States' Assembly & Constitution Committee	The Reform (Guernsey)(Amendment) Law 2020	P.2020/99	Approved (as amended)
    Propositions (as amended)	Propositions (as amended) [193kb]		See below
    Voting Record	Proposition 1 [139kb]	n/a	Carried
    Voting Record	Proposition 2 [139kb]	n/a	Carried
    Voting Record	Proposition 3 [139kb]	n/a	Lost
    Amendment 1	Deputy McSwiggan & Deputy Soulsby [407kb]	P.2020/99 Amdt 1	Carried
    Voting Record	Amendment 1 [107kb]	n/a	n/a
    Amendment 2	Deputy de Sausmarez & Deputy Roffey [230kb]	P.2020/99 Amdt 2	Lost
    Voting Record	Amendment 2 [108kb]	n/a	n/a
    Amendment 3	Deputy Trott & Deputy St Pier [274kb]	P.2020/99 Amdt 3	Carried
    Voting Record	Motion under Rule 24.(6) on Amendment 3 [108kb]	n/a	Lost
    Voting Record	Amendment 3 [107kb]	n/a	Carried
    Civil Contingencies Authority	Emergency Powers (Coronavirus) (General Provision) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (No. 2) (Amendment) Regulations, 2020	P.2020/103	Approved

• Elections and Appointments

  • Billet	Billet Article	Committee/Body	Title	Proposition Reference	Status
    XII	1	Presiding Officer	Election of Members of The Ladies' College Board of Governors	P.2020/98	Approved

• Legislation for Approval

  • Billet	Billet Article	Committee/Body	Title	Proposition Reference	Status
    XI	1	Policy & Resources Committee	The Alderney Property Tax (Enabling Provisions) Law, 2020	P.2020/62	Approved
    XI	2	Committee for Health & Social Care	The Human Tissue and Transplantation (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Law, 2020	P.2020/63	Approved
    		Voting Record	Proposition 1 [107kb]		Approved (Pour 25; Contre 14)
    XI	3	Committee for Home Affairs	The Population Management (Guernsey) (Amendment) Law, 2019 (Commencement) Ordinance, 2020	P.2020/64	Approved (as amended)
    		Amendment 1	Deputy Lowe & Deputy Leadbeater [515kb]	P.2020/64 Amdt 1	Carried
    XI	4	Policy & Resources Committee	The Machinery of Government (Transfer of Functions) Ordinance, 2020	P.2020/65	Approved (as amended)
    		Amendment 1	Deputy Le Tocq & Deputy Trott [499kb]	P.2020/65 Amdt 1	Carried
    XI	5	States' Trading Supervisory Board	The Pilotage (Amendment) Ordinance, 2020	P.2020/66	Approved (as amended
    		Amendment 1	Deputy Ferbrache & Deputy Smithies [232kb]	P.2020/66 Amdt 1	Carried
    		Amendment 2	Deputy Ferbrache & Deputy Smithies [233kb]	P.2020/66 Amdt 2	Carried
    XI	6	Committee for Economic Development	The Banking Deposit Compensation Scheme (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Amendment) Ordinance, 2020	P.2020/67	Approved
    XI	7	Policy & Resources Committee	The Taxation of Real Property (Guernsey and Alderney) (Amendment) Ordinance, 2020	P.2020/68	Approved (As amended)
    		Amendment 1	Deputy Le Tocq & Deputy Trott [234kb]	P.2020/68 Amdt 1	Carried

• Propositions and Policy Letters

  • Billet	Billet Article	Committee/Body	Title	Proposition Reference		Status
    XI	8	Committee for the Environment & Infrastructure	States of Guernsey Energy Policy 2020-2050	P.2020/47		Approved
    		Letter of Comment	Policy & Resources Committee [771kb]	P.2020/47 P&RC Lett Comm
    		Voting Record	Proposition 4b [106kb]			Carried (Pour 35; Contre 1; Abstain 3)
    		Voting Record	Propositions 8 & 9 [105kb]			Carried (Pour 34; Contre 2; Abstain 3)
    		Amendment 1	Deputy Brehaut & Deputy Ferbrache [586kb]	P.2020/47 Amdt 1		Carried
    		Amendment 2	Deputy de Lisle & Deputy Inder [597kb]	P.2020/47 Amdt 2		Lost
    XI	9	Policy & Resources Committee	Review of the Jurisdiction of The Ecclesiastical Court in relation to Grants of Representation regarding Personal Property	P.2020/53		Propositions 1,3, 4 & 5 Approved. (Proposition 2 Rejected)
    		Voting Record	Proposition 1 [107kb]			Carried (Pour 21; Contre 17; Abstain 1)
    		Voting Record	Proposition 2 [107kb]			Lost (Pour 17; Contre 21; Abstain 1)
    		Voting Record	Proposition 3 [107kb]			Carried (Pour 25; Contre 13; Abstain 1)
    XI	10	Policy & Resources Committee	Amendments to the Legal Framework Relating to Beneficial Ownership of Legal Persons	P.2020/72		Approved
    		Voting Record	Propositions 1.1.vi, 1.2.ii & 1.3 [156kb]			Carried (Pour 30; Contre 8)
    XI	11	Policy & Resources Committee	Minor Changes to the Document Duty (Guernsey) Law, 2017	P.2020/70		Approved
    XI	12	Committee for Employment & Social Security	Diffuse Mesothelioma Payment Scheme	P.2020/73		Approved
    		Voting Record	All Propositions [136kb]			Carried (Pour 39)
    		Sursis Motivé	Deputy Le Tocq & Deputy Stephens [613kb]	P.2020/73 Surs		Rejected
    		Voting Record	Sursis Motivé [139kb]			Lost (Pour 5; Contre 33)
    XI	13	Committee for Health & Social Care	Urgent Capital Bid - Replacement of the Electronic Patient Record System	P.2020/74		Approved
    		Letter of Comment	Scrutiny Management Committee [634kb]	P.2020/74 SMC Lett Comm
    		Voting Record	All Propositions [105kb]			Carried (Pour 29; Contre; 6; Abstain 4)
    XI	14	Committee for Economic Development	Proposed Amendments to the Preferred Debts (Guernsey) Law, 1983	P.2020/59		Approved
    XII	1	States' Assembly & Constitution Committee	Dates of States' Meetings - 1st September 2020 to 31st August 2021	P.2020/93		Approved (as amended only by Amendments 2 & 3 in the final substantive vote)
    		Voting Record	Proposition 1B (as amended) [137kb]			Carried (Pour 28; Contre 10)
    		Voting Record	Proposition 1C (as amended) [137kb]			Carried (Pour 37)
    		Amendment 1	Deputy Dorey & Deputy Ferbrache [511kb]	P.2020/93 Amdt 1		Carried
    		Voting Record	Amendment 1 [140kb]			Carried (Pour 23; Contre 16)
    		Amendment 2	Deputy Dorey & Deputy Ferbrache [410kb]	P.2020/93 Amdt 2		Carried
    		Voting Record	Amendment 2 [140kb]			Carried (Pour 23; Contre 12; Abstain 4)
    		Amendment 3	Deputy Soulsby & Deputy Tooley [522kb]	P.2020/93 Amdt 3		Carried
    		Voting Record	Amendment 3 [139kb]			Carried (Pour 39)
    		Amendment 4	Deputy Gollop & Deputy Merrett [231kb]	P.2020/93 Amdt 4		Not Laid
    XI	15	Policy & Resources Committee	Schedule for future States' business [525kb]	P.2020/75		Approved (as amended)
    		Amendment 1	Deputy Soulsby & Deputy Tooley [414kb]	P.2020/75 Amdt 1		Carried
    		Voting Record	Amendment 1 [138kb]			Carried (Pour 30; Contre 8; Ne vote pas 1)
    		Amendment 2	Deputy Lowe & Deputy Leadbeater [501kb]	P.2020/75 Amdt 2		Carried
    		Voting Record	Amendment 2 [138kb]			Carried (Pour 29; Contre 10)

• Procedural Motions brought by the Presiding Officer during debate

  • 	Status
    22/5/2020 - Motion to reconvene the Meeting on 3rd June to complete items on Billet XI [103kb]	Carried (Pour: 21 Contre: 13)
    22/5/2020 - Motion for the States to consider the Schedule for future States' business on 22nd May 2020 [104kb]	Lost (Pour: 17 Contre: 9)

     

Downloads

Share this page