States Meeting on 8 September 2021 (Billet d'Ètat XVII)

Items discussed at this Meeting included, Proposals for Secondary Education, Guernsey's participation in the UK's Free Trade Agreements and Committee Elections.

• Watch the States of Deliberation Meeting online

  • States' Meetings are only available to watch back for 180 days. The Hansard Report of what was said in the Meeting is available in the downloads section.

• Statements 

  • Statement to be given by	Topic
    Policy & Resources Committee	General Update
    Committee for Economic Development	General Update

    A link to each statement is published once it has been delivered in the States Meeting

• Questions

  • Verbal Questions posed to Committee Presidents under Rule 11

  • Questioner	Responding Committee	Topic	No. of Questions
    Deputy St Pier	Committee for Economic Development	Public Trustee Accounts	Two
    Deputy St Pier	Civil Contingencies Authority	Civil Contingencies Law	One
    Deputy Burford	Policy & Resources Committee	Equal pay for work of equal value	Three
    Deputy Gollop	Policy & Resources Committee	Vaccination certificates	Two
    Deputy Queripel	Committee for Health & Social Care	Immune system supplements	Three

  • The questions and their responses will be published in Hansard

• Appointment laid before the States

  • Committee	Title
    Committee for Economic Development	Appointment of an Ordinary Member of the Guernsey Competition and Regulatory Authority [167kb]

• Appointments and Elections

  • Billet d'État	Billet Article	Committee	Title	Proposition Reference	Status
    XXVII	1	Presiding Officer	Election of a Member of the Committee for Home Affairs	P.2021/88	Deputy Sue Aldwell elected unopposed
    XXVII	2	Presiding Officer	Election of a Member of the Development & Planning Authority	P.2021/89	Deputy Bob Murray elected unopposed
    XXVII	3	Presiding Officer	Election of a Member of the Transport Licensing Authority	P.2021/90	Deputy Liam McKenna elected unopposed

• Items deferred from the Meeting on 14th July 2021

  • Billet d'État	Billet Article	Committee	Title	Proposition Reference	Status
    XXVII	4	Committee for Education, Sport & Culture	Secondary and Post 16 Education Reorganisation	P.2021/69	All Propositions Carried unamended
    		Proposition 1	Voting Record [164kb]		Carried Pour 23; Contre 16
    		Proposition 2	Voting Record [164kb]		Carried Pour 22; Contre 17
    		Propositions 3 & 4	Voting Record [167kb]		Carried Pour 22; Contre 14; Abstain: 3
    		Amendment 1	Deputy Cameron & Deputy de Sausmarez [380kb]	P.2021/69 Amdt 1	Lost
    		Amendment 1	Voting Record - Amendment 1 [165kb]		Lost Pour 17; Contre 22
    		Rule 26.(1) Guillotine Motion on Amendment 1	Voting Record - Guillotine Motion to close debate on Amendment 1 - Deputy Dyke [169kb]		Lost Pour 8; Contre 30
    		Amendment 2	Deputy Leadbeater & Deputy De Lisle [240kb]	P.2021/69 Amdt 2	Lost
    		Amendment 2	Voting Record - Amendment 2 [169kb]		Lost Pour: 14; Contre: 22; Abstain: 3
    		Amendment 3	Deputy Leadbeater & Deputy de Lisle [235kb]	P.2021/69 Amdt 3	Lost
    		Amendment 3	Voting Record - Amendment 3 [166kb]		Lost Pour 12; Contre 27
    		Amendment 4	Deputy Le Tocq & Deputy Cameron [332kb]	P.2021/69 Amdt 4	Motion under Rule 24(6) was successful so the Amendment was not not debated and no vote taken
    		Motion under Rule 24(6)	Voting Record [170kb]		Carried Pour; 20; Contre:15; Absent: 4
    		Amendment 5	Deputy Le Tocq & Deputy Brouard [255kb]	P.2021/69 Amdt 5	Lost
    		Amendment 5	Voting Record - Amendment 5 [167kb]		Lost Pour 14; Contre 22; Abstain 2; Absent 1
    		Rule 26.(1) Guillotine Motion on Amendment 5	Voting Record [169kb]		Lost Pour 19; Contre 19; Absent 1
    		Amendment 6	Deputy St Pier & Deputy Cameron [322kb]	P.2021/69 Amdt 6	Not laid
    		Amendment 7	Deputy St Pier & Deputy Cameron [252kb]	P.2021/69 Amdt 7	Not laid
    		Amendment 8	Deputy Trott & Deputy Parkinson [255kb]	P.2021/69 Amdt 8	Lost
    		Amendment 8	Voting Record [165kb]		Lost Pour 16; Contre 20; Abstain 1
    		Rule 26.(1) Guillotine Motion on Amendment 8	Voting Record [168kb]		Lost Pour 12; Contre 27;
    		Amendment 9	Deputy Matthews & Deputy Gollop [260kb]	P.2021/69 Amdt 9	Not laid as motion to suspend the Rules failed
    		Motion to suspend the Rules to allow Amendment 9 to be laid	Voting Record [170kb]		Lost Pour: 13; Contre: 24; Abstain: 0; Absent: 2
    		Amendment 10	Deputy St Pier & Deputy Cameron [248kb]	P.2021/69 Amdt 10	Not laid as motion to suspend the Rules failed
    		Motion to suspend the Rules to allow Amendment 10 to be laid	Voting Record [169kb]		Lost Pour 16; Contre; 21; Absent 2
    		Amendment 11	Deputy St Pier & Deputy Cameron [251kb]	P.2021/69 Amdt 11	Lost  Pour 11; Contre; 23; Abstain 4; Absent 1
    		Amendment 11	Voting Record - Amendment 11 [167kb]		Lost Pour 11; Contre 23; Abstain 4; Absent 1
    		Rule 26.(1) Guillotine Motion on Amendment 11	Voting Record [169kb]		Carried Pour 20; Contre 15; Abstain 1; Absent 3
    XXVII	5	Policy & Resources Committee, Committee for Economic Development and States' Trading Supervisory Board	Guernsey Electricity - Interim Amendments For Tariff Regulation	P.2021/65	Approved
    		Proposition 1	Voting Record [168kb]		Carried Pour 21; Contre 7; Abstain 1; Absent 10
    		Proposition 2	Voting Record [167kb]		Carried Pour 21; Contre 7; Abstain 1; Absent 10
    		Proposition 3	Voting Record [167kb]		Carried Pour 22; Contre 6; Abstain 1; Absent 10
    		Amendment 1	Deputy de Sausmarez & Deputy Haskins [264kb]	P.2021/65 Amdt 1	Not laid
    		Amendment 2	Deputy de Sausmarez & Deputy Haskins [276kb]	P.2021/65 Amdt 2	Carried
    		Amendment 2	Voting Record - Amendment 2 [167kb]		Carried Pour 28; Contre 5; Abstain 1; Absent 5
    XXVII	6	States' Assembly & Constitution Committee	General Election 2020: Reports from the CPA BIMR Election Expert Mission and the Registrar-General of Electors	P.2021/46	Deferred to 29th September 2021

• Legislation laid before the States

  • The Building (Guernsey)(Amendment) Regulations, 2021

    The Customs and Excise (Safety and Security) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Amendment) Regulations, 2021

    The Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Regulations, 2021

    LEGISLATION LAID BEFORE THE STATES [159kb]

• Urgent Propositions pursuant to Rule 18

  • Committee	Title	Proposition Reference	Status	Voting Record
    Civil Contingencies Authority	Emergency Powers (Coronavirus) (General Provision) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (No. 10) Regulations, 2021	P.2021/99	Carried Pour: 37; Contre; 2	Voting Record [170kb]
    Civil Contingencies Authority	Emergency Powers (Coronavirus) (Vaccine) (Limitation of Liability) (No. 10) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Regulations, 2021	P.2021/100	Carried Pour 36; Contre: 2; Abstain 1	Voting Record [168kb]

• Legislation for Approval

  • Billet d'État	Billet Article	Committee	Title	Proposition Reference	Status
    XXVII	7	Policy & Resources Committee	Amendments to the Court of Appeal (Guernsey) Law, 1961	P.2021/72	Deferred to 29th September 2021
    XXVII	8	Policy & Resources Committee	The Insurance Business (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Amendment) Ordinance, 2021	P.2021/73	Approved
    XXVII	9	Policy & Resources Committee	The Insurance Managers and Insurance Intermediaries (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Amendment) Ordinance, 2021	P.2021/74	Approved
    XXVII	10	Policy & Resources Committee	The Regulation of Fiduciaries, Administration Businesses and Company Directors, etc (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Commencement) Ordinance, 2021	P.2021/75	Approved as amended
    		Amendment 1	HM Procureur & HM Comptroller [192kb]	P.2021/75 Amdt 1	Carried
    XXVII	11	Policy & Resources Committee	The Protection of Investors (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Commencement) Ordinance, 2021	P.2021/76	Approved
    XXVII	12	Policy & Resources Committee	The Financial Services Business (Enforcement Powers) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Commencement) Ordinance, 2021	P.2021/77	Approved
    XXVII	13	Policy & Resources Committee	The Banking Supervision (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Commencement) Ordinance, 2021	P.2021/78	Approved

• Propositions and Policy Letters

  • Billet d'État	Billet Article	Committee	Title	Proposition Reference	Status
    XXVII	14	Committee for the Environment & Infrastructure	The Island's Future Aggregate Supply	P.2021/83	Deferred to 29th September 2021
    		Policy & Resources Committee	Letter of Comment: The Island's Future Aggregate Supply [348kb]	P.2021/83 Lett Comm
    XXVII	15	States' Trading Supervisory Board	Guernsey Electricity Limited - Annual Report and Accounts	P.2021/80	Deferred to 29th September 2021
    XXVII	16	Committee for Home Affairs	Amendments to Customs Law - Seizure and Disposal of Perishable Goods	P.2021/81	Deferred to 29th September 2021
    XXVII	17	Policy & Resources Committee	The Bailiwick's Participation in UK Free Trade Agreements	P.2021/82	Approved
    XXVII	18	Policy & Resources Committee	Schedule for Future States' Business [232kb]	P.2021/84	Approved

• Appendix Reports

  • Committee for Home Affairs	Guernsey Prison Annual Report 2020 [878kb]
    Committee for Home Affairs	Guernsey Prison - Independent Monitoring Panel - 2020 Annual Report [318kb]

     

Downloads

Share this page