States Meeting on 30th March 2022 (Billets d'Ètat VI & VII)

Items discussed at this Meeting included the Capacity (Powers of Attorney) Ordinance, Electronic Voting in the States of Deliberation and the Establishment of a Development Agency

Re-Watch the States of Deliberation Meeting online
States' Meetings are only available to re-watch for 180 days. The Hansard Report of what was said in the Meeting is available in the downloads section.
Statements
Statement to be given by Topic
Policy & Resources Committee General Update
Committee for Economic Development General Update
A link to each statement is published once it has been delivered in the States Meeting
Questions (Rule 11)
Questions being asked by: Questions
Deputy Gollop to the Scrutiny Management Committee 1. Will the Scrutiny Management Committee be considering a full public review and project considering the Bailiwick's external transport needs and aspirations for local passengers and the visitor economy?
2. Back in 2016 the then States Scrutiny Committee reviewed air transport links for both Guernsey and Alderney . Will this workstream by re-evaluated and updated?
3. Will the Scrutiny Management Committee be inputting ideas into any reorganization of our system of government especially with regards to coordination of departments responsible for aspects of external transport policy infrastructure and regulatory oversight?
The Questions and their replies will be published in Hansard in due course
Election
Billet d'État Billet Article Sponsor Title Proposition Reference Status
VI 1 Policy & Resources Committee Election or Mr Stuart King as an Ordinary Member of the Guernsey Financial Services Commission P.2022/16 Approved
Appointments laid before the States
Billet d'Ètat Committee Title
VI Committee for Economic Development Appointment of an Ordinary Member of the Office of the Financial Services Ombudsman - Antony Townsend [171kb]
VI Committee for Economic Development Appointment of an Ordinary Member of the Office of the Financial Services Ombudsman - Robert Girard [166kb]
Motion to Debate an Appendix Report
Proposed Seconded Status Voting Record
Motion to Debate the Appendix Report titled 'IDP Annual Monitoring Report 2020' [95kb] Deputy de Lisle Deputy Gollop Approved
Pour 15; Contre 11; Abstain 4; Absent 9 Voting Record [164kb]
The Motion to Debate was successful and debate on the Appendix Report has been deferred to the Meeting on States Meeting on 27th April 2022 (Billet d'État VIII).
Legislation to be laid before the States
No. 167 of 2021 - The Health Service (Payment of Authorised Appliance Suppliers) (Amendment) Regulations, 2021
No. 168 of 2021 - The Health Service (Payment of Authorised Suppliers) (Amendment) Regulations, 2021
No. 170 of 2021 - The Health Service Fund (Closure and Miscellaneous Amendments) Regulations, 2021
No. 171 of 2021 - The Health Service (Pharmaceutical Benefit and Medical Appliances) (Amendment) Regulations, 2021
No. 175 of 2021 - The Health Service Benefit (Miscellaneous Provisions) Regulations, 2021
No. 2 of 2022 - The Parochial Elections (St Peter Port) Regulations, 2022
LEGISLATION LAID BEFORE THE STATES [162kb]
Legislation for Approval
Billet d'État Billet Article Committee Title Proposition Reference Status
VI 2 Committee for Home Affairs The Police Force (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Amendment) Law, 2021 (Commencement) Ordinance, 2022 P.2022/12 Approved
VI 3 Committee for Health & Social Care The Capacity (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Law 2020 (Commencement) (Guernsey and Alderney) Ordinance 2022 P.2022/13 Approved
VI 4 Committee for Health & Social Care The Capacity (Lasting Powers of Attorney) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Ordinance, 2022 P.2022/14 Approved (as amended)
Recorded vote on Proposition Voting Record - Proposition (as amended) [166kb] Approved
Pour 36; Contre 0; Abstain 0; Absent 3
Amendment 1 Her Majesty's Comptroller & Deputy Brouard [230kb] P.2022/14 Amdt 1 Carried
Voting Record Voting Record - Amendment 1 [170kb] Carried
Pour 34; Contre 0; Abstain 0; Absent 5
Propositions and Policy Letters
Billet d'État Billet Article Committee Title Proposition Reference Status
VI 5 States' Assembly & Constitution Committee Simultaneous Electronic Voting in the States of Deliberation P.2022/15 Approved
Voting Record Propositions 1 to 3 [168kb] Carried
Pour 28; Contre 9; Absent 2
Voting Record Proposition 4 [166kb] Carried
Pour 27; Contre 10; Absent 2
Voting Record Rule 26(1) Guillotine motion to close debate - Deputy St Pier [169kb] Lost
Pour 16; Contre 19; Abstain 1; Absent 3
Voting Record Rule 26(1) - Fresh Division under Rule 26(9) - on the Guillotine motion to close debate - Deputy Haskins [169kb] Lost
Pour 15; Contre 19; Abstain 1; Absent 3
VI 6 Policy & Resources Committee Establishment of a Development Agency P.2022/11 All Propositions Approved (as amended)
Propositions (As Amended) [155kb]
Voting Record Proposition 1 [166kb] Carried
Pour 34; Contre 1;
Absent 4
Voting Record Proposition 1a [167kb] Carried
Pour 26; Contre 9;
Absent 4
Voting Record Proposition 2 [165kb] Carried
Pour 28; Contre 7;
Absent 4
Voting Record Proposition 2a [167kb] Carried
Pour 30; Contre 5;
Absent 4
Voting Record Proposition 3 [164kb] Carried
Pour 24; Contre 11;
Absent 4
Voting Record Proposition 3a [167kb] Carried
Pour 26; Contre 7;
Abstain 2; Absent 4
Voting Record Proposition 4 [162kb] Carried
Pour 24; Contre 11;
Absent 4
Voting Record Proposition 5 [166kb] Carried
Pour 33; Contre 2;
Absent 4
Voting Record Proposition 6a [167kb] Carried
Pour 25; Contre 9;
Abstain 1; Absent 4
Voting Record Proposition 6b [166kb] Carried
Pour 26; Contre 8;
Abstain 1; Absent 4
Amendment 1 Deputy Oliver & Deputy Taylor [189kb] P.2022/11 Amdt 1 Carried
Amendment 2 Deputy Burford & Deputy Soulsby [290kb] P.2022/11 Amdt 2 Carried
Amendment 3 Deputy St Pier & Deputy Helyar [484kb] P.2022/11 Amdt 3 Carried
Amendment 4 Deputy St Pier & Deputy Helyar [523kb] P.2022/11 Amdt 4 Carried
Amendment 5 Deputy St Pier & Deputy Helyar [481kb] P.2022/11 Amdt 5 Carried
Amendment 6 Deputy St Pier & Deputy Helyar [470kb] P.2022/11 Amdt 6 Carried
Voting Record Rule 26(1) Guillotine motion to close debate - Deputy Inder [166kb] Carried
Pour 23; Contre 11; Abstain 3; Absent 2
Amendment 7 Deputy Gollop & Deputy de Lisle [496kb] P.2022/11 Amdt 7 Successful Motion under Rule 24(6). As a result the amendment was not debated and no vote taken
Amendment 8 Deputy Meerveld & Deputy Burford [190kb] P.2022/11 Amdt 8 Lost
Voting Record Voting Record - Amendment 8 [168kb] Lost
Pour 10; Contre 24; Abstain 2; Absent
Amendment 9 Deputy Roffey & Deputy Parkinson [269kb] P.2022/11 Amdt 9 Lost
Voting Record Voting Record - Amendment 9 [167kb] Lost
Pour 15; Contre 19; Abstain 2; Absent 3
Amendment 10 Deputy de Sausmarez & Deputy Soulsby [220kb] P.2022/11 Amdt 10 Not laid
Amendment 11 Deputy Roffey & Deputy Parkinson [336kb] P.2022/11 Amdt 11 Successful Motion under Rule 24(6). As a result the amendment was not debated and no vote taken
Voting Record Motion under Rule 24(6) that Amendment 11 not be debated and no vote taken [171kb] Carried
Pour 18; Contre 14; Absent 7
Amendment 12 Deputy de Sausmarez & Deputy Soulsby [221kb] P.2022/12 Amdt 12 Carried
Voting Record Carried
Pour 22: Contre 11; Abstain 2; Absent 4
Voting Record Rule 26(1) Guillotine motion to close debate - Deputy Prow [168kb] Carried
Pour 20; Contre 13; Abstain 2; Absent 4
VII 1 Policy & Resources Committee States of Deliberation's response to the Russian Federation's invasion of Ukraine P.2022/24 Propositions 1, 2-6 and 8 Approved. Proposition 7 lost
Amendment 1 Deputy St Pier & Deputy Ferbrache [228kb] P.2022/24 Amdt 1 Carried
Amendment 2 Deputy St Pier & Deputy Soulsby [193kb] P.2022/24 Amdt 2 Carried
Voting Record - Proposition 1 Proposition 1 [179kb] Carried
Pour 37; Contre 0; Abstain 0; Absent 2
Voting Record - Propositions 2 - 6 (as amended) Propositions 2 - 6 [215kb] Carried
Pour: 36; Contre 0; Abstain 1; Absent 2
Voting Record - Proposition 7 (as amended) Proposition 7 [181kb] Lost
Pour 15; Contre 21; Abstain 1; Absent 2
Voting Record - Proposition 8 (as amended) Proposition 8 [189kb] Carried
Pour: 34; Contre 3; Abstain 0; Absent 2
VI 7 Policy & Resources Committee Schedule for Future States' Business [215kb] P.2022/17 Approved
Appendix Report
Committee Appendix Report Motion
Development & Planning Authority Island Development Plan - Annual Monitoring Report 2020 [3Mb] Motion to Debate - Deputy de Lisle & Deputy Gollop [95kb]

St Peter Port & St Sampson

All Other Parishes

States Meeting on 30th March 2022 (Billets d'Ètat VI & VII)

Downloads

Share this page

Re-Watch the States of Deliberation Meeting online

Statements

Questions (Rule 11)

Election

Appointments laid before the States

Motion to Debate an Appendix Report

Legislation to be laid before the States

Legislation for Approval

Propositions and Policy Letters

Appendix Report

Downloads

Share this page

Statement to be given by	Topic
Policy & Resources Committee	General Update
Committee for Economic Development	General Update

Billet d'État	Billet Article	Sponsor	Title	Proposition Reference	Status
VI	1	Policy & Resources Committee	Election or Mr Stuart King as an Ordinary Member of the Guernsey Financial Services Commission	P.2022/16	Approved

Billet d'Ètat	Committee	Title
VI	Committee for Economic Development	Appointment of an Ordinary Member of the Office of the Financial Services Ombudsman - Antony Townsend [171kb]
VI	Committee for Economic Development	Appointment of an Ordinary Member of the Office of the Financial Services Ombudsman - Robert Girard [166kb]

	Proposed	Seconded	Status	Voting Record
Motion to Debate the Appendix Report titled 'IDP Annual Monitoring Report 2020' [95kb]	Deputy de Lisle	Deputy Gollop	Approved Pour 15; Contre 11; Abstain 4; Absent 9	Voting Record [164kb]

Committee	Appendix Report	Motion
Development & Planning Authority	Island Development Plan - Annual Monitoring Report 2020 [3Mb]	Motion to Debate - Deputy de Lisle & Deputy Gollop [95kb]